Sunday, March 25, 2018

Change is Essential

I seem to really have a soft spot for niche phones. I've had a Moto X , a Nexus 5, and a BlackBerry PRIV just to name a few.

I've done it again. I just bought an Essential PH-1. In late 2017 it was estimated that only about 50,000 had been sold. That makes the BlackBerry PRIV look like a runaway success at about 600,000 sold.

Essential was founded by Andy Rubin, the inventor of Android.

It's a gorgeous phone closely resembling the iPhone X in appearance and size.


Here's how it compares to my iPhone 6s.

Apple iPhone 6sEssential iPhone
DESIGN
Device typeSmart phoneSmart phone
OSiOS (10.x, 9.x)Android (7.1)
Dimensions5.44 x 2.64 x 0.28 inches (138.3 x 67.1 x 7.1 mm)5.57 x 2.80 x 0.31 inches (141.5 x 71.1 x 7.8 mm)
Weight5.04 oz (143 g)6.53 oz (185 g)
MaterialsMain body: AluminumMain body: Ceramic; Accents: Titanium
FeaturesFingerprint (touch)Fingerprint (touch)
DISPLAY
Physical size4.7 inches5.7 inches
Resolution750 x 1334 pixels1312 x 2560 pixels
Pixel density326 ppi504 ppi
TechnologyIPS LCDIPS LCD
Screen-to-body ratio65.71 %84.85 %
Colors16 777 21616 777 216
TouchscreenMulti-touchMulti-touch
FeaturesPressure-sensitive, Oleophobic coating, Scratch-resistant glass, Light sensor, Proximity sensorScratch-resistant glass (Corning Gorilla Glass 5), Ambient light sensor, Proximity sensor
CAMERA
Camera12 megapixels13 megapixels
   Aperture sizeF2.2F1.9
   Focal length (35mm equivalent)29 mm
   Camera sensor size1/3"
   Hardware
   Features
Sapphire crystal lens cover, Autofocus, Back-illuminated sensor (BSI)Dual-camera (13-megapixel), Autofocus (Laser, Phase detection)
   Software
   Features
Touch to focus, Face detection, Self-timer, Geo taggingTouch to focus, Face detection, Self-timer, Digital zoom, Geo tagging
Camcorder3840x2160 (4K) (30 fps), 1920x1080 (1080p HD) (120 fps), 1280x720 (720p HD) (240 fps)3840x2160 (4K) (30 fps), 1920x1080 (1080p HD) (60 fps), 1280x720 (720p HD) (120 fps)
   FeaturesTime-lapse video, Continuous autofocus, Digital image stabilization, Video calling, Video sharingVideo calling, Video sharing
Front-facing camera5 megapixels8 megapixels
HARDWARE
System chipApple A9 APL0898Qualcomm Snapdragon 835 MSM8998
ProcessorDual-core, 1840 MHz, Twister, 64-bitOcta-core, 2450 MHz, Kryo 280, 64-bit, 10 nm
Graphics processorPowerVR GT7600Adreno 540
System memory2048 MB RAM4096 MB RAM
Built-in storage64 GB128 GB
Maximum User Storage

Storage expansion

BATTERY
Talk time14.00 hours
Stand-by time10.0 days (240 hours)
Capacity1715 mAh3040 mAh
Not user replaceableYesYes
Wireless charging

MULTIMEDIA
Music player
   Filter byAlbum, Artist, Genre, PlaylistsAlbum, Artist, Genre, Playlists
   FeaturesAlbum art cover, Background playbackAlbum art cover, Background playback
SpeakersEarpiece, LoudspeakerEarpiece, Loudspeaker
YouTube playerYesYes
INTERNET BROWSING
Built-in online services supportYouTube (upload), Picasa/Google+YouTube (upload), Picasa/Google+
TECHNOLOGY
CDMA800, 1700/2100, 1900 MHz800, 1900 MH
GSM850, 900, 1800, 1900 MHz850, 900, 1800, 1900 MHz
UMTS850, 900, 1700/2100, 1900, 2100 MHz850, 900, 1700/2100, 1900, 2100 MHz
FDD LTEBands 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 12, 13, 17, 18, 19, 20, 25, 26, 28, 29Bands 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 12, 13, 17, 20, 21, 25, 26, 28, 29, 30
DataLTE-A Cat 6 (300/50 Mbit/s), HSPA, HSUPALTE-A Pro Cat 16 (1000/150 Mbit/s)
micro-SIM

nano-SIMYesYes
PositioningGPS, A-GPS, Glonass, Galileo, Cell ID, Wi-Fi positioningGPS, A-GPS, Glonass
NavigationTurn-by-turn navigation, Voice navigationTurn-by-turn navigation, Voice navigation
CONNECTIVITY
Bluetooth4.25.0
Wi-Fi802.11 a, b, g, n, ac, dual-band802.11 a, b, g, n, ac, dual-band
   Mobile hotspotYesYes
USBYesYes
   ConnectorProprietaryUSB Type-C (reversible)
   FeaturesUSB chargingUSB charging
HDMI

OtherNFC, Tethering, Computer sync, OTA syncNFC, Tethering, Computer sync, OTA sync
OTHER FEATURES
NotificationsService lights, Haptic feedback, Music ringtones (MP3), Polyphonic ringtones, Vibration, Flight mode, Silent mode, SpeakerphoneService lights, Haptic feedback
SensorsAccelerometer, Gyroscope, CompassAccelerometer, Compass, Gesture
Hearing aid compatibilityM3, T4
OtherVoice dialing, Voice commands, Voice recording, TTY/TDDVoice dialing, Voice commands, Voice recording
AVAILABILITY
Officially announced09 Sep 201530 May 2017
FCC Approval09 Sep 201526 Jun 2017
Source: phoneArena.com


The day after I got it it updated to Oreo 8.1.

Then I sold it within a week.

Why?

I searched for a spring-clip belt holster without finding one. I know that is only slightly less geeky than a pocket protector but it is what I'm used to.

My bank's debit card doesn't support Google Pay. Apple Pay is supported.

The PH-1 has a weak vibration motor like the OnePlus One.

I tried to use Dropbox to move pictures from the PH-1 to my PC. Most of the pictures I was saving were being texted to me so they were in Android Messages. Messages saves them in Photos / Messages and Dropbox wouldn't look there for the Camera Uploads process.

I like the physical muting switch on the iPhone. Android has a complicated "Do not disturb" process that involves stared contacts, downtime and priorities. I just want it to not make any sounds but to still vibrate.

The fingerprint reader on the Essential is so much better than the iPhone 6s. It's in a natural place and reads quick.

Both of my Bluetooth ear buds misbehaved on the PH-1. They tended to switch the audio between ears occasionally and then switch right back. It wasn't continuous and wasn't very frequent.

The PH-1 uses USB C for charging and earphones. I had to buy USB A to USB C cables. While this was a short term hassle, long term it is clearly the direction.

Android is not nearly as aggressive as iOS at throttling apps running in the background. Even after Oreo 8.1 GasBuddy used 10% of my battery capacity on the PH-1 and I had NEVER launched it. The flip side of this is that iOS doesn't give Google Maps' location services frequent GPS updates. This makes my Google Maps Timeline have poor resolution (more on this later). Similarly Google Maps often opens with the wrong location on the iPhone.

Android Oreo 8.1 is really improving battery life (after I uninstalled GasBuddy). Admittedly my sample is very small but the mAh/hour for the PH-1 on Oreo 8.1 was 68.5 compared to 52.8 for the iPhone 6s for the last 5 weekdays I tracked. There are more details here.

I can't believe I gave up a flagship Android for a 2 year old iPhone but I did.

No comments: