I never wanted an iPhone anyway. ;)
I had been watching Android phones. AT&T was slow to get Android phones, perhaps because they had the iPhone. They finally got the HTC Aria and the Samsung Captivate (a Galaxy S variant).
My rationale was to wait until these devices were upgraded to Android 2.2. The reason was that I wanted the newest Gmail and Google Docs applications and tethering (really unlikely due to AT&T).
Then the battery in my BlackBerry Bold started to get less and less capacity. And the holster broke. I needed some kind of excuse!
I thought I wanted the Aria until I touched the Captivate. It's so slim and light and the OLED screen is so bright!
Just before Christmas I discovered that AT&T had refurbished Captivates on their web site for $9.99. Yes, the decimal is in the correct place.
Compared to the iPhone 4 the Captivate is lighter with a bigger screen. And it doesn't need iTunes. Did I mention that it's cheaper?
There's a great comparison here.
When it arrived, I had never played with an Android. I spent the next 12 hours playing. It's amazing.
I use Google Hosted Apps to host the e-mail for my domain so I was able to use my domain e-mail as the Google account. I expected everything to work smoothly but I wasn't prepared for how well integrated all the Google services were.
I was used to the BlackBerry BIS e-mail being quick to deliver but it was really a copy of my Google e-mail. So when I deleted an e-mail from the BlackBerry I still had to dispose of it on my Google e-mail. On the Captivate, I can archive an e-mail on the phone and when I look over to my web Google e-mail, the e-mail has disappeared.
The calendar is the same. Today I created an event on my web Google calendar. As soon as I saved it, the phone buzzed. That was the notification for the new event.
I have been challenged by the battery life. I did all the suggestions I found in the forums with little success. AT&T exchanged the phone for me and the new one seems to be some better but still erratic. Most days I have 50%-60% at the end of the work day but then some days it'll be 20% and complaining. I can't discern a pattern nor cause. I've just laid in microUSB cables at strategic locations to recharge but I really haven't needed them.
I use Wi-Fi (802.11n) heavily at home and at work. The work network uses 802.1x authentication and with a little fiddling it works great.
The original phone's GPS was good. This is apparently a problem area with Galaxy S phones. The new phone's GPS is Ok but not as good as the original phone. I guess I'd rather have better battery life than a quick GPS.
I'm not an app hog but I've installed a number of apps from the market. AT&T has restricted the Captivate to only Android Market apps but that hasn't been an issue.
Here's what I've installed:
- Graffiti Pro for Android
- Car Cast Podcast Planner
- Classic Tetris - Game Blaster S
- gReader (Google Reader)
- FourSquare - foursquare
- Barcode Scanner - ZXing Team
- Text Edit - Paul Mach
- Dropbox - Dropbox
- Klondike Solitaire - Softick
- Angry Birds - Rovio
- GPS Test - Chartcross Limited
- GDocs - WildArt
- GPS Logger for Android - Mendhak
- WeatherBug - WeatherBug Mobile
- NOOK for Android - Barnes & Noble
- Google Voice - Google
- Google Maps - Google
I haven't rooted it like I did the NOOKcolor and don't expect to. If Samsung and AT&T don't ever deliver Android 2.2 then I'll have to reconsider this.